You are here /wrestling
/guests
/John C.
Guest Columns

John C.

Main

BLAH

THE JOHN REPORT
King of the Ring Winners from the Past and a Prediction for KOTR 2000

In today's column I will take you on a journey that will look at the first seven winners of the prestigious King of the Ring (KOTR) tournament. I will also take a look at this year's field as I throw out a few opinions as to which wrestler I would put the crown on. Without further adieu, here she blows...

The King of the Ring is a make or break event

When the WWF realized that wrestling fans were tired of waiting for four months between WrestleMania and Summerslam they came up with the King of the Ring tournament in 1993. The format was simple: Place several midcarders into a single elimination tournament and showcase them on PPV. The winner of the tournament will receive a push later in the year. If all goes well, he could be a main eventer in the future.

Considering the King of the Ring is the youngest of the "Big Five" WWF PPV's it is one of those events where the fans demand excellence. However, if you look at past KOTR events and in particular, the KOTR winners, then you will see that results are not always great although it has helped launch the career of a few guys.

When WWF personnel talk about the history of the KOTR they only mention the names of Steve Austin and Triple H. As far as they are concerned, nobody else won the tournament in years past or so it seems. When you take a look at the first seven winners of the KOTR you can see that only one of them will be wrestling at this year's PPV on June 25th. He is of course, the current world champion Triple H. Past KOTR winners include a WCW employee, a deceased individual, a man nursing a severe neck injury and a WWF employee who is on a leave of absence so he could go back to ultimate fighting. You also have last year's winner who is currently on the shelf with a shoulder injury and then you have a man who wears a pool cover to the ring or at least that's what it likes look and as mentioned, you have the current world champion. Because it is fun to look at the journey of past winners, here's a look at the past seven Kings of the Ring.

Winner of the 1993 King of the Ring: Bret Hart

This was the inaugural KOTR tournament so the WWF probably figured the best way to show fans that this was a serious event would be to put the title on their former world champion. Bret was coming off a loss to Yokozuna (who subsequently lost it to Hulk Hogan in a matter of seconds) at "the worst PPV ever" WrestleMania IX so he needed momentum again. He was probably the biggest face at the time despite Hogan's attempts at stealing the spotlight. Throw in the fact that he was a world champion and he instantly gave the King of the Ring label the credibility it needed in order to get over with fans.

In the first match he went on to defeat Razor Ramon just like he did at the Royal Rumble a few months prior. Following that, he defeated Curt Hennig (wrestling as my hero Mr. Perfect) and Bam Bam Bigelow on his way to becoming the first KOTR. However, the celebration did not last long as Bret's next feud would start immediately. During his "coronation" ceremony Jerry Lawler, who claimed that he was the only King in the WWF, attacked Bret leading to one of the best feuds the WWF has ever had. If the WWF were smart they would have made this feud over the world title instead of the horrible Luger/Yokozuna feud that bombed worse than Janet Reno would at a comedy festival. Oh well, live and learn I guess. Ironically, that feud ended two years after it began at KOTR '95. Regardless of that faux pas, giving Bret Hart the title of the first ever KOTR was a good move because it gave credibility to the event thus giving fans a reason to watch it for years to come.

Winner of the 1994 King of the Ring: Owen Hart

For the second year of the KOTR tourney, the WWF decided that they would help out a midcarder instead of an already established main eventer. Before the event even started, it seemed obvious who was going to win. Considering he defeated his brother Bret at WrestleMania X on the previous PPV all signs pointed to an Owen Hart victory at KOTR '94 and that's exactly what happened. At the PPV he defeated Tatanka, he then beat the 1-2-3 Kid (Sean Waltman aka X-Pac) in a beautiful match during the semifinals and in the finals he beat Razor Ramon who was the babyface favourite at the time.

The feud with Bret started at Survivor Series '93, continued at Royal Rumble '94 and finally led to a match at WMX. Following his win at KOTR, Owen dropped the nickname of "The Rocket" and demanded to be known as the "King of Harts" which is a name that stuck with him for a while (until he "won" his Slammy Awards). Due to the fact that the WWF was embroiled in the steroid trial their product on screen suffered except for the Hart/Hart feud that captivated wrestling fans for nearly a year. Owen received his shot at the world title at Summerslam '94 in a wonderful 30-minute cage match against Bret Hart. Even though he lost the match he proved to the world that he was capable of being the number one heel in the company. Owen never did get to wear the world title but in 1994 it felt as though he was the man who was on top of the wrestling world thanks to his King of the Ring victory.

Winner of the 1995 King of the Ring: Mabel

After writing about two of the greatest wrestlers in WWF history it's time to talk about one of the biggest busts. For those that are too young to remember, Mabel is the artist currently known as Viscera. Yes folks, everybody makes mistakes and this was the WWF's biggest KOTR mistake. For a few years Mabel was a part of the hip-hop tag team known as Men on a Mission with his partner Mo who was seemingly just as bad as Mabel despite weighing 200 pounds less. Then, for some strange reason, the WWF decided to push Mabel as a singles star even though wrestling fans (particularly smart ones) would rather watch Roseanne wrestle Oprah in a mud-wrestling match. Yes kids, he was THAT bad and as you all know, he still is. Anyway, the logical booking would have seen Shawn Michaels or The Undertaker given the crown to continue the streak of giving the title to guys with, you know, TALENT.

Instead of logic, Mabel defeated The Undertaker thanks to a Kama run-in and received a bye into the finals because he's a fat bastard who could not get away from the buffet table long enough to wrestle three times in one night. Okay well, the real reason was because Kama wrestled Michaels to a draw (nice booking huh?) which led to Mabel squashing Savio Vega in the finals. Sadly, they booked Mabel as the #1 heel which led to arguably the worst title match in WWF history against Diesel at Summerslam '95. The bottom line is that everybody makes mistakes and this was definitely one of the WWF's biggest mistakes ever. If you want to know which King of the Ring to avoid, you have your answer right here. Now, let us never speak of this again as it provides me with nothing but painful memories.

Winner of the 1996 King of the Ring: Steve Austin

The term "coming out party" best suits the next King of the Ring winner because on this night the entire wrestling industry had a feeling that a star was born. I'm willing to wager that 90% of the people reading this column know exactly what happened at KOTR '96 as it was one of those special nights in wrestling history. Prior to KOTR '96 Austin was in a transition where he was phasing out the putrid Ringmaster gimmick in favour of the more outgoing Stone Cold gimmick while still maintaining his heel status. After defeating Savio Vega at WrestleMania XII in impressive fashion, Austin lost the blowoff match in the Vega feud as well the services of his manager Ted Dibiase. He was on his own finally given the chance to shine based on his tremendous amount of talent.

As opposed to the first three tourneys, this KOTR tournament would only feature the semifinals and finals so that the undercard could be filled with other matches involving midcarders. With a new gimmick in place and the ability to be himself Austin realized what an opportunity this was. In the first KOTR semifinal, Austin defeated Marc Mero (who was still a babyface accompanied by Sable) in a match that saw Austin win with a Stunner. During the course of the match, Austin received a busted lip that required over a dozen stitches. In the finals he met Jake Roberts who was returning as a face that put a lot of faith in the bible. In Roberts' earlier match he was attacked by Vader so much that they claimed he received "broken ribs." Austin showed no remorse for Roberts and won cleanly as he immediately climbed the ladder as one of the WWF's best heels. The night didn't end there for Austin though because his greatest accomplishment may have taken place during his promo afterwards. As Roberts was headed to the back Austin said: "You can talk about your psalms, you can talk about your John 3:16. Well, Austin 3:16 says I just whipped your ass!" He ended the interview by using a catchphrase you all have heard many times which is of course, "and that's the bottom line 'cause Stone Cold said so."

Austin's rise to the top began at a time when the WWF was in need of good workers at the top of the card. As an added bonus, Owen Hart did guest commentary for the PPV that turned out to be hilarious. He would go on to have a memorable feud with Bret Hart that would last for over a year before his epic feud with Mr. McMahon developed. Owen's run as KOTR winner in '94 gave us better matches but Austin's run was obviously the one with more historical value.

A Little History Lesson

Before I get into the next part there is an interesting story about who was supposed to win KOTR '96. According to wrestling insiders, Triple H was scheduled to win KOTR '96 but due to the infamous "MSG Incident" he was taken out of the tournament. The MSG Incident took place in the spring of '96 while Triple H and HBK's friends Scott Hall and Kevin Nash had their last matches in the WWF. Triple H wrestled Scott on the undercard while Shawn wrestled Kevin in the main event. Following Shawn's successful title defense against Nash, Triple H and Scott came out where they hugged in the ring as a way of saying goodbye to the new WCW employees. As you know, the four of them (along with Sean Waltman) were real life best friends who were known as "The Clique." The group hug was not planned so as a punishment Vince McMahon took Triple H out of the tournament and instead booked Steve Austin to win it all. Michaels was not punished because he was the world champion so it was Hunter who had to do some jobs instead of receiving a push. In '97, when Shawn and Triple H first formed DX they showed a clip of this hug although when they showed the clip it was merely a part of an angle. The point of the story is this: Had Triple H not participated in the "MSG Incident" Steve Austin may not have become one of the most successful wrestlers of all-time. Funny how things work out isn't it?

Winner of the 1997 King of the Ring: Hunter Hearst Helmsley

Before there was ever "The Game" the man known as Triple H was wrestling under the gimmick of a rich snob. Hailing from Greenwich, Connecticut, he wore long robes, he bowed to the booing crowd and he did whatever he could to piss the fans off. The gimmick was okay although it was not enough to carry him to main event status and that's why we are supposed to forget about his original gimmick. The year that he dropped the rich snob gimmick was 1997 but it was after he was crowned King of the Ring.

Just like the year before, the PPV matches only featured the semifinals and finals. In the semis, Helmsley wrestled Ahmed Johnson who some of you may know as Big T. over in WCW although he hasn't been seen much probably because he found a buffet table he really liked. Anyway, he defeated Ahmed because he was slowly being phased out of WWF storylines at the time (thank you!). His opponent in the finals would turn out to be the man that has given him his greatest matches and that of course is Mick Foley who was wrestling as Mankind at the time. At the time, Mankind had been in the WWF for nearly a year and was slowly morphing into a face. Triple H went on to defeat Mankind in the finals and capture the KOTR title marking the fourth consecutive year of a heel winning.

Thankfully for us, the feud with Mankind was only beginning as the two wrestled again at the Canadian Stampede PPV in July and Summerslam in August. Although Triple H won the first match between the two it was Foley that won the feud at Summerslam when he morphed from Mankind into Dude Love to take the victory. Meanwhile, Triple H slowly showed who he really is as he began aligning himself with his best friend Shawn Michaels on screen. Once September rolled around the rich snob gimmick was phased out and Hunter was wrestling as part of the hot new stable known as DX. He remained a heel until DX started receiving cheers in May of '98, which allowed him to act like himself instead of portraying a character. The opinion of many people, including me, was that Triple H would not make it to the top. After adding more muscle to his physique and developing his overall talent he has become one of the best heels that wrestling has seen in many, many years.

Winner of the 1998 King of the Ring: Ken Shamrock

Of the seven King of the Ring winners the most forgotten winner is probably Ken Shamrock. It's not really his fault though. The reason his victory is overlooked is because of the memorable Mankind/Undertaker Hell in a Cell match that took place on the same card. Shamrock made his first WWF appearance a year before this event and since that time he had developed into an accomplished wrestler. He was not a great worker, per se, but he was capable of having good matches with the right opponents. His transformation from ultimate fighter to pro wrestler was a smooth one as he was able to wrestle opponents of all sizes and still look very good in the ring. For many months he had been feuding with the Nation of Domination and in particular, The Rock who was a heel at the time. Shamrock forced the Rock to tap out at WrestleMania XIV in an IC title but the decision was reversed because Shamrock would not release the ankle lock. Heading into the PPV the fans expected to see that feud go to a whole new level.

The way the tournament was booked it looked as though we would get to see a Shamrock vs. Severn match in the finals that would surely fill the appetite of those of us who love ultimate fighting. Shamrock did his part by defeating Jeff Jarrett cleanly in round one while Severn lost to The Rock thanks to interference from D'Lo Brown. This time around, when Shamrock had the Rock in the ankle lock he did let go. The Rock tapped out giving Shamrock the King of the Ring title and possibly a renewed push. As it turns out, the push never really materialized as the WWF started to focus a lot more on personalities rather than wrestling. Shamrock was not phased out; it's just that there was no spot for him in the upper echelon so he toiled in the midcard for the next year and a half before leaving for the ultimate fighting world. He'll be back next year but the question is, will anyone care about him like they did when he won King of the Ring?

Winner of the 1999 King of the Ring: Billy Gunn aka "Mr. Ass"

In 1999, the WWF went back to the format they used in the first three years of the tournament. They had eight wrestlers start out in the tournament meaning that the winners would have to wrestle three times barring a DQ or countout. The biggest news story heading in to this event was that DX had broken up and all of the members were wrestling in singles. Billy Gunn and Chyna were the heels while Road Dogg and X-Pac were the face members of the former group. Also, heading into the event there was a lot of hype on the net that claimed the Big Show would win the tournament because he was featured in all the ads. Considering the way they heavily hyped the DX breakup it seemed obvious that the winner would be a member of the former DX. The only question was, who would it be? Since the PPV was booked in the Russo-esque "Crash PPV" mode I might as well zip through the results as well. Gunn defeated defending champion Ken Shamrock in round one followed by victories over Kane in the semis and his former DX buddy X-Pac in the finals.

After four months of being a singles wrestler, Mr. Ass was back with the Road Dogg as one half of the New Age Outlaws. The reason he failed to step up to the next level is because of his lame promos, which only proved who the talented one really was in the New Age Outlaws. Throw in the fact that he is not a great worker, the fans could care less about him as a heel and you have yourself a failure. While I am not a fan of Gunn, I must give him some props because he is one of the best athletes the WWF has. When someone as accomplished as Steve Austin goes out of his way, on more than one occasion, to say that he'd be willing to put Billy Gunn over it is a compliment I hope Gunn takes to heart. If he works on the promos a bit more he can make up for his lack of pure wrestling talent. Personally, I'd rather listen to George W. Bush singing his version of "I'm the Real Slim Shady" before I listen to another one of Gunn's promos. I don't think he has what it takes to be a huge star but maybe he can prove me wrong like Triple H did.

Summary

As you can tell from the information I shared above, the winner of the King of the Ring does not always become a huge star. While Bret Hart, Steve Austin, Triple H and Owen Hart will be remembered as four of the best WWF wrestlers ever while Ken Shamrock and Billy Gunn will do their best to climb the WWF ladder again although both men may have missed their golden opportunity. As for Mabel's win, let's remember that as one of the worst booking decisions the WWF has ever done. I think Steve Austin and Triple H deserve to be remembered as the two most successful winners but I think Owen Hart had the best matches on the night he won the crown.

Winning the King of the Ring tournament does not necessarily mean you will be a main eventer but it does help your chances greatly. Even though the last two tournament's have not produced "great" winners it is still a tournament that every wrestler would like to win because of the opportunity he or she will receive after capturing the coveted crown.

Who will win King of the Ring 2000?

I am not going to sit here and book a fantasy tourney using the 16 participants in KOTR 2K because it has been done and will be done up until the event takes place on June 25. If you want a more detailed preview of the event wait for the World's Greatest King of the Ring Preview that "the fifth member of the Horsemen" drqshadow and myself will bring to you the Friday before the event. What I will do is take a look at some of the top contenders for this year's crown. Before I get to that, here's a look at the 16-person field that will take part in this year's KOTR.

Here they are using the order they are listed on WWF.com: Kurt Angle, Rikishi Phatu, Bull Buchanan, Crash Holly, Chyna, Val Venis, Chris Benoit, Hardcore Holly, Chris Jericho, Eddy Guerrero, Buh Buh Ray Dudley, Perry Saturn, X-Pac, Jeff Hardy, Edge and Scotty Too Hotty. Now, here's a look at the wrestlers who I feel are the top contenders.

Kurt Angle: He seems to be the obvious choice. The person that wins KOTR will need to use that claim in order to get over more and because Angle is already over huge he does not need the claim as much as somebody else. He may be in the finals; it's just that I don't think he will win it all.

Rikishi Phatu: He's a guy that can be thrown into the same group as Angle. Rikishi is over huge, he has a huge backing and he has a gimmick (the stinkface) that people care about. However, he has a feud with Val Venis so I'm guessing that Val will cost him his spot in the tournament and they will go on to feud for the next PPV.

Chris Jericho: Another one of the obvious choices. Jericho is my second choice for winning although he is so over now and he is so ready for main event status that he may not need this honor. He is so close to main event level he could headline the next PPV if it was booked properly. Usually it takes time to build the winner up to that level so when you consider that CJ is at that level already I'd look elsewhere for a winner. He would not be a bad choice; it's just that he seems ready for the next level right now instead of six months from now.

My choice for the winner of King of the Ring 2000 is...

Chris Benoit: The current Intercontinental champion is slowly building himself up as a world title contender. He is not there yet but a win at the King of the Ring would be the catapult he needs in order to get there. His heel heat has gone up in the last couple of weeks while the quality of his matches remains the same: absolutely phenomenal. He is the most consistent performer in wrestling today as well as being the best worker of this generation. A victory at this year's tournament would definitely help him get over even more considering he is already the IC champion. If he wins this tournament he will be headlining the PPVs by the end of this year hopefully against a returning Steve Austin. Now THAT would be a dream match.

If one of those four do not win the King of the Ring I will be surprised. I think other wrestlers that will go far in this tourney are:

Bull Buchanan - The WWF is really high on this guy even though he is very dull. Eddy Guerrero - A good showing here could propel him to IC title level. Eddy is God. Val Venis - He is finding new life as a heel. Feud with Rikishi is on the horizon. Hardcore Holly - Always comes close but rarely wins the big ones.

I think the other competitors could benefit from a long run in the tournament but I don't see any of them going as far as the semifinals. It should be a good tournament although I am not sure how they will fit fifteen tournament matches on one PPV. Obviously the matches will be short due to the main event and the other two or three matches that will fill the card so don't count on any match of the year candidates. Despite the full card, the sixteen people that make up this year's field is the best the WWF has ever had. As always, drq and I will be back for the preview next Friday.

In Closing...

I hope you enjoyed today's column about the history of the King of the Ring. It was a lot of fun going down memory lane once again and reminiscing about the past. Speaking of memory lane, I think it is in your best interests that you check out the Big 3 Wrestling Oratory because we have been teaching a lot of history lessons lately as drqshadow continues his wonderfully detailed look at the Four Horsemen. Also, Adam Karabel will review a WWF superstar, Roland Geary chimes in with his thoughts on the Great American Bash and Matt Spence returns from a drunken haze (!) to analyze Raw. This coming weekend we will be posting the newest Joint Oratory Column from the Oratory staff. What will the subject be? You'll have to wait until Sunday to find out. All of this and more can be accessed at the #1 wrestling column site on the Internet and all you have to do is click HERE!

On a personal note, I asked my girlfriend Jena to marry me on Friday night and she said yes. We are not sure when the wedding will be but it'll probably be next spring or early next summer since neither of us wants to get married in cold weather. Contrary to popular belief, it DOES get warm here in Ontario. I also want to wish all of my fellow dads out there a Happy Father's Day. Although I would not consider it a holiday because we are off work anyway I still enjoy spending time with my grandpa, my dad and my son. It's always a fun time and I'm looking forward to the weekend.

If you have any questions or comments about this column feel free to MAIL ME and I will do my best to reply to you as soon as possible. Remember to vote for Carlos Delgado for the all-star game because he is the best first basemen in the American League. Have a great week and remember, Lakers in six!

Smell ya later,
John C.
Big3 Oratory

Mail John C.
AOLIM: JohnC1104
When we promise a "big surprise" we actually deliver. It's true. It's true.

BLAH

Main

Design copyright (C) 1999, 2000 Christopher Robin Zimmerman & KZiM Communications
Guest column text copyright (C) 2000 by the individual author and used with permission