/wrestling /awards /General Comments |
1999 R.S.P-W Awards | General Comments |
Awards |
General Comments This entire document copyright 1999 by Christopher Robin Zimmerman. Portions of this document are copyright 1990-95 by Herb Kunze and used with his kind permission. Visit Herb's Awards page at <http://www.twc-online.com/herb/Awards.html>. *PLEASE* CONTACT ME FIRST BEFORE USING ANY PART OF THESE RESULTS!! I can be reached by emailing chris@kzim.com. First, some general comments... TORREY M. SPEARS: Wrestling, as a whole peaked in 1999 with the mainstream media... never again will it be some 'backwoods hick' thing. At the same time, Sports Entertainment will rule the next millenium..... 'wrestling' as we knew it is dead. LARRYBUD: #1 story of the year is Owen Hart's death at "Over the Edge" and the reaction from it. #2 story is the tumult in the WCW from the firing of Bischoff to hiring of Russo/Ferrerra. Thanks for making this possible! SCOTT GRIFFITH: That was a lot of fun! Thanks for the effort CRZ, and keep up the good work. Sorry I don't read your recaps on Wrestline. haha The Netcop is just funnier for my recapping dollar. SVEN MASCARENHAS: Compared to 1998, 1999 was a horrible year for wrestling in North America. While Mankind had an incredible year, the success of one of the true nice guys of wrestling doesn't balance the loss of class acts such as Rick Rude and Owen Hart. Match quality and lengths dropped across the board (and almost overnight in WCW), political pressure killed angles, and others that should have been wiped out at the moment of their conception were allowed to continue. Yet there were bright lights: for the first time in a long time, it seemed as if we're finally going to be able to get rid of the stars of the 80s who somehow stuck around to become the stars of the 90s. The WWF has a ton of young talent just waiting for Austin to finally move into acting (now, who does that sound like?) in Edge, Christian, the Hardyz, Papi Chulo, Kurt Angle, D'Lo Brown and Test. WCW can look into the next decade safe in the knowledge that they've got Chris Benoit, Billy Kidman, and especially Bill Goldberg under their wing. And ECW has Lance Storm, the man who's my pick to be the next Bret Hart, waiting until Mr. 4:20 moves into the mainstream and gets crushed just as badly as he did last time. So while the year may have been bad, there were some notable bright spots and plenty of hope for the future. Oh, one last thing: Test gets the consensus Rookie of the Year award, I should think. BILL LEHECKA: The WWF outdistanced it's competitor this year. It put on more cognitave, entertaining shows. Granted there was a lack of wrestling compared to WCW, the storylines made up for it, from Rock and Mankind, to Chris Jericho's introduction to the WWF, it was the year of the WWF. That's all I really have to say. I might add an addendum, if that's OK. Later. JBELL55146: WWF and ECW pretty much stayed content with little spurts here and there while WCW might as well have had Celine Dion singing 'My Heart Will Go On' cuz they sank faster then the Titanic ever could. Hopefully they will get their heads on straight and put forth a good 2000. JOHN C.: Thanks for allowing me to vote and I look forward to the results and comments. Take care. RICHARD BEAUBIEN: Welcome to the year of Sports Entertainment, as WCW went clearly over to the side of sport entertainment and WWF continued to win the ratings battle. People changed sides, the front office was shooked up, and in the end I'm less optimistic about the future of wrestling at the end of this year then last year. Last year it seemed like the WCW would go into a new age without Hulk Hogan and provide us with quality wrestling thanks to the lWo. Hulk Hogan returned, and WCW went down the crapper. Now Hulk Hogan is gone again, but we all know he'll be back to pollute the air waves. And with Russo at the helm, sport entertainment at WCW will never allow to deliver a quality 10 minute cruiserweight match again. Not enough T&A I guess... The WWF continued on it's course, and desptie the fact the ideas seem a bit bland to me at years end they have remained true to form. Which is a angle driven, storyline company. The arrival of Jericho helped liven things up, and the Hardyz and The Holly's entertained me. But the HHH angle doesn't intrest me, and the WWF had some really big stinkers this year, mostly involving either the females or Kane and the Big Slow. So as we hit Y2J head on, things look grim for a turn to quality wrestling. The rating are high, and WCW seems determined to become the WWF so it looks like a shift back to work rate is less and less likely. And as the old war horses Ric Flair and Brett Hart walk into the fading sunset, as Chris Benoit seems destined to get the short end of the stick regardless of who's running WCW. The fact that Hulk Hogan might be doing an Austin gimmick soon.... But maybe the new fans may tire of the new age soap opera. Maybe they'll leave and allow the old fans to come back, to see the stars of the new generation craft a legacy. Not based solely on promos and angels, but on great work rate. Maybe we'll have our Steamboat/Flair for the next cenutry... Maybe...But I wouldn't count on it.... DMIKESTER: First off, CRZ, I want to say thank you. You have given me many hours of enjoyment and satisfaction at seeing a recapper who really cares about what he's doing and knows what he's talking about. There are only a handful of reporters like you, and you are one of the best of those proud few. Thank you. I based the beginning on "wrestling" talent, something that seems to have been forgotten by everyone except the most dedicated wrestling fans. The reason I watch ECW more than WWF now is because of the wrestling that still exists there. I also watch WCW when there's a match like Bret Hart v. Chris Benoit. I've been going through the 'Net and many people who have been talking about their nominations have said Steve Austin is the best wrestler of the year when they don't even consider how horrible he's become since he became a babyface in the WWF. JAMIE COVILLE: On the "worst" stuff it's hard to pick just three ;) STACY MCMACKIN: Next year, eliminate the "Best Jobber" and "Best Jobber To The Stars" categories. The concept makes no sense, a wrestler is a wrestler. Sometimes they win, sometimes they lose. The only time when "jobber" was an appropriate term in wrestling was when they actually had squash matches on wrestling tv shows where one guy ALWAYS WON and one guy ALWAYS LOST. They no longer do that... everybody sometimes wins and sometimes loses these days. GRAHAM PRESTON: This year was pretty lackluster and will become one of the most notorious years of wrestling history. Wrestling became Sports Entertainment, drew massive ratings, and ... Owen. Hopefully his death will not be relegated to trivia games, and tongue in cheek references. One can only hope wrestling will go back more to its roots whil keeping some SE, to attract the diehard smarts to the blowjob obsessed typical 10-12 year old catchphrase memorising, DD only, type people. Thank god for November '98 to about March '99 Corporation/Rocky type stuff to save this year from almost complete boredom. Hopefully this time next year I'll be writing about Benoit's 5 month title reighn in which he got mega over, and became a GOD~! to smarks, marks and smarts. I'm out. CHRIS VAUGHN: This year's nominees GREATLY upsets me. This poll is VERy workrate, and by no means covers all aspects of wrestling. It kills me to see that you cannot even put Hulk Hogan in the best wrestler category. Yes, he is old. Yes, he's not a great wrestler, but he's still one of the best entertainers in the business, and wrestling is Sports Entertainment. Hogan was included in evey category that was in any way a category that put wrestlers down. Not everyone is a mark for good technical wrestling, and quality grappling! (IE: Chris Benoit, Bret Hart) Remember, not everyone shares your opinions on good wrestling. (Hello! Where were you when we were nominating? Also, you were free to vote for people thta weren't nominated. I guess it helps to READ THE RULES, huh? - CRZ) THE H-BOMB: I can't believe that Chris Benoit won "Jobber to the Stars" last year. I voted, and ignored him because he did earn wins. He was deserving of a push, but he wasn't fed to every at Eric Bischoff's whim. Taka is someone deserving of a push, but at the same time doesn't collect any wins at all. And that, my friend, is why he is your "Jobber to the Stars" this year! "Most Improved" is a tough category this year. I've only begun watching ECW in September, since I'm in the deprived country of Canada :) , so I can't acurately give any of their performs any votes. What I'm left with is WWF and WCW stars, who in most cases always had the skills, but was finally given a chance by their promotion. Such is the case with Hardcore Holly. Many people may argue, but he had the skill all along. It wasn't as evident as "Spark Plug", but in the New Midnight Express, I got to see his talent. I give Lenny number 1, for the sole reason that if he had talent, WCW didn't even care to show it. Instead of jobbing while showcasing his skills, he was plain and simply doing Barry Horowitz's job. I didn't vote in either Major Show category, because I didn't feel that I could vote seeing how I was unable to watch any of the Major Shows over the past year, because in September of '98 the stupid cable company pulled pay-per-view. Call me crazy, but Little Guido always has good matches, thus I included him as one of my picks for best wrestler of the year. TOXICENEMA: After a great year for wrestling in 1998, 1999 was a big letdown. WCW hit the absolute rock bottom in terms of PPV's, and angle development. Its choatic, dartboard booking was at the absolute worst this year. It's too bad, because solid workers like Kanyon, Guerrero and the like will be overlooked for WWF talent that was pushed correctly (Edge, Hardyz) . WWF started out really good, but lost its way after WM, not having a legitimate heel to foil Rock or Austin. They spent most of the summer trying to create HHH into that mold, boring the audience. But the audience had no alternatives to turn to. ECW lost a few steps with a combination of pushing the wrong people (New Jack, Balls&Axl) and losing alot of workers (Sandman, Taz, Douglas) . GREGG MIXDORF: This year in wrestling seemed to be a down year for in the ring competition. With only three matches to really chose from. I have gotten sick and tired of the entertainment side of the equation outweighing the sports side. Take for example last night (11/29/99) way to much wedding and not enough action. The wedding itself seemed to last for an eternity. I'm digressing here but I think this point needs to be brought out. Wrestling needs to start focussing on wrestling again. This problem has been amplified by the fact that WCW has gone to the crash t.v. format. You no longer can catch a good long match on monday nights anymore. You have to wait untill Friday nights and sit through a bunch of commercial breaks to do so. I would really like to see ECW go to a two hour format and allow almost everyone of their matches to go ten minutes a peice. This would be great and allow those of us who like actuall in ring wrestling to be able to see it. I'm sad to say it but I miss the old Nitro. I miss Billy Kidman in a ten minute match against Juventud. Damn do I ever miss those great cruserweight matches that Russo seems intent on getting rid of. I want more of that and I can't get it. I thought you missed an obvious category with best up and comming wrestler. A young talent who will be very good and very over some day. Papi Chulo is my favorite young talent in the WWF right now. I go nuts everytime he is on Jakked/Metal. I have begun watching these shows just to be able to watch him wrestle. Got to see him and TAKA Michinoku go at it one night. It was a terriffic match. I want more. I hope that Papi and Amy Dumas do get paired up like I read somewhere. That would be fantastic. Another guy that has me cheering everytime he is on my t.v. is Kurt Angle. This guy is a great heal. I'm amazed at the heat he is receiving so early on in his career. I really enjoy his style, kind of reminds me of Brett Hart in a way but maybe that has more to do with his build and patriotism than anything else. The other young guy that I really enjoy is Blitzkrieg. Although I haven't seen him for a while I was real impressed with him when he was on. A variety of cool moves and great high flying ability. I want more Blitzkrieg! Thanks for this opportunity to vote on this year in wrestling. Have a great New year and continues success in the future. BLANK: Does anyone notice that FIVE of the nominated matches for Worst Match were from that Legends abomination? Can we let that die??? I know you don't accept multiple votes for the same event, but Owen Hart's death so far overshadowed everything else that it was a statement vote. Same with the Heroes of Wrestling -- God, what one card can do to wreck wrestling... I didn't order it, and I still thought it was the worst card of all time... MARK SMITH: For my comments, I'd just like to say thanks to CRZ for always busting his ass to make sure things are getting done in the online wrestling world. We love ya, Chris. CHRIS FAIRBANKS: Goddamn, that's a long email! And it took so long to copy and paste! And it's really late at night! And I have class in a few hours! Crap! BEN MILLER: I hate to point out specific worst ofs, but Kevin Nash as booker and the Onita matches in New Japan were two of the worst angles, promotional moves, etc. in the time I have been watching wrestling. Without question, 1996 was the greatest year I have ever seen in wrestling and the reason it became my passion, and I am amazed how far it has fallen in match quality and risen in profits over the past three years. I always like to think of what five American wrestlers I would select if given a draft, and after this year, I would take Rock, Jericho, Booker T, Juventud and Benoit. I think within a year I could deliver great matches along with cool angles that draw with those four on top and Juvy headlining some cruiserweights. DC1CB1: Watching ECW as I type this. Gertner is making me laugh my ass off with his Pokemon jokes during the Super crazy match. I prefer to see more wrestling. I can remember watching wrestling and wondering what was gonna happen IN the ring. Wish it would get back to that some more. Got email address from Wresteline.com 3. ANDREW: Triple H is one of the best heels I've ever seen. B. SZPAKOWICZ: Well... a strange year. No real dominant wrestlers or teams, unlike last year, with titles changing all over the place for no good reason and no one getting more than about 2 months with any particular belt. Could someone please tell the WWF and WCW that wrestler getting a nice *long* title reign every once in a while isn't going to instantly scare away all the viewers? For that matter, neither are matches going more than five or ten minutes. No particularly great matches either, though a lot of good and/or fun ones. I'm hardly one of those people who demands a ***** match on every second show, but one or two matches over ****1/4 would be nice. The only match to have totally blown me off my feet was the Ladder Match, and even that was badly flawed. No angles to match Austin-McMahon also, either in longevity or greatness, though a few came damn close. (read: Y2J, WWF Champion Mick Foley) . And then there was Brian, and Gorilla, and Ravishing Rick. And Owen. Jesus Christ, *why*? ! OTOH, the sport is just hotter than its ever been, the WWF in particular batting monstrous ratings and buyrates every time out. And we also saw the emergence of ECW as a bona fide force in the business. So, all told, was the year a good one? A bad one? An average? Probably the latter, really, but mostly it was just... strange. THERION: Overall comments - the "worst of" sections need a top five instead of a top three. The best of's manage to stand out, but there were so many worsts this year that it was hard to choose. COLIN MACKINNON: Chris, you've been doing a great job with the RSPW Awards, and it's nice to see you're in charge again this year. I think I speak for everyone who voted when I say "Thank you" for a job well done. You've also done a fine job with your web site and the RAW/Nitro/Smackdown recaps, and at times, it's hard to see where you actually find all this free time. :) Thanks again, and Happy Holidays. CRAIG MALIN: DX (NAO/XPac) are terrible as heels because they play to the crowd so much. They should follow HHH's lead. XPac looks like a six year old riding a mechanical horse when he does the Bronco buster. I know you love Blackman but he's gotta learn to at least look at the camera during an interview!! SELENA KYTE: I realize I'm a rarity in two areas so far as pro wrestling fans are concerned. I'm a woman who prefers female wrestling to male wrestling, and I'm a person who prefers to be entertained by some semblance of wrestling. Both elements have been in short supply throughout the past few years; none more so than in 1999. I've gone from being angry about the situation to a tolerance and an understanding of today's form of pro wrestling, which is clearly not aimed towards me. Everyone naturally votes for what they regularly see. For the most part, I've stopped watching WWF and WCW programming around five years ago. If I'm alerted to something worthwhile involving women on a WCW show through the e-mail discussion group I belong to, the Women's Wrestling Mailing List, I may tune in to watch the match. Otherwise, I prefer to dedicate my time and energy to learning and supporting the women on the independent circuit and those wrestling in other countries, to the extent that I can. My purpose in contributing to this year's poll is to highlight some women whose actions I felt were deserving of attention this year beyond those in the WWF, WCW, and ECW. With one current all female promotion looking to have more live events next year, and at least three new all female promotions looking to start up next year, my hope is that more women wrestling serious matches will be introduced to fans looking for alternatives to the major promotions. I would also like to see more mention of women's pro wrestling matches from other countries besides Japan, like Australia, Mexico, and Nigeria. Maybe then, there will be a more balanced representation on year end polls like this one. CHAS DORMAN: WWF had a strong year dominating the ratings again. They picked up key free agents like Jericho, Wight, and Taz. Austin vs McMahon kept things interesting, and when it died down they gave McMahon HHH to feud with. That feud looks promising as the wedding angle only made that better. WCW had an off year, but now that Bischoff is gone and the young guys are getting soem good angles, they shoudl be better next year. The "Powers That BE " angle can help them out, but only if they stay away from Amway commercials and focus on the in ring hinderance of certain stars. I look for more competition next year as both shows will get attention for their "crash TV" styles. OLIVER DAVIES: Have never seen any Japanese promotions, therefore I can't vote on them. Other awards I'd give: Most underappreciated match of the year: Ken Shamrock v Undertaker at Apr. In Your House, Favourite T & A moment: Mud wrestling on Smackdown, most promising wrestlers: Chris Jericho, Jeff Hardy, Edge. Most surprising talents: Shane Douglas, Kane, Most surprising match: Shane v Test at Summer Slam, most memorable spot: ending of ladder match at No Mercy, Best chemistry: Hands down - Rock and Mick Foley I've finally gotten access to ECW, I suspect that if I'd seen more of them this year they would have gotten my vote for promotion of the year. JASON BALDWIN: I don't feel right voting for (or against) anything or anybody I haven't seen. I'm sure some of the Japanese stars (probably all of them) are better technicians & flyers, but based on my limited exposure to their work (none of it from this year) , I can't in good conscience vote on them. This sums up my approach to voting: Good babyface = I mark out. I like you. Bad babyface. I change the channel. You bore me. Good heel = I boo you. I hate you. Bad heel = I change the channel. You bore me. Simple enough, eh? And despite its popularity, I thought this was just a rather pitiful year for wrestling in general. Or maybe I'm just changing. ROB EVANS: General Comments - CRZ rocks! Thanks for taking the time to facilitate the awards once again. STINGER: ECW Rules. Sports Entertainment (short matches, wedding and Co.) sucks. See ya. Wrestling fan from Poland. |
Intro General Comments Best Wrestler Best Tag Team Best Heel Best Babyface Best Worker Best Jobber Best Jobber to the Stars Best Flyer Best Technical Best Brawler Most Favourite Most Improved Most Overrated Best Gimmick Best Move Best Match Best Feud Worst Wrestler Worst Tag Team Worst Heel Worst Babyface Worst Worker Least Favourite Most Deteriorated Most Underrated Worst Gimmick Worst Move Worst Match Worst Feud Most Disappointing News item Most Obnoxious Best Second Best Announcer Best Colour Best Interviewee Best Angle Best Organization Best TV Show Best Major Show Best Promotional Move Worst Second Worst Announcer Worst Colour Worst Interviewee Worst Angle Worst Organization Worst TV Show Worst Major Show Worst Promotional Move 'netter Suggested Awards |
Main |